top of page

The Austin Factors: Is Confinement Actually More Effective Than Probation?

Writer: Andrew Fair
Andrew Fair
1 day ago
4 min read


By Andrew Fair, MNJRC Intern


In Minnesota, before a judge can revoke someone's probation and send them back to prison, they must weigh three legal criteria established by the Minnesota Supreme Court, known as the Austin Factors. This comes from the Minnesota Supreme Court decision in State of Minnesota v. Austin (1980). Judges must consider the following:


  • Identify the specific condition violated: The judge must name the exact court-ordered rule or term of probation that was broken.

  • Determine the violation was intentional or inexcusable: The court must establish that the failure was deliberate or lacked a valid excuse, rather than being an accident.

  • Prove that the need for confinement outweighs the policies favoring probation: The judge must balance the individual's liberty and rehabilitation against public safety.


The High Cost of Technical Violations


“I had a home, a job, and worked on rebuilding my relationship with my son. A technical violation not only sent me to prison, but I will also have to start over once I am released. The mother of my son does not want him to see me in prison, prolonging the rebuilding of this relationship.”

— Anonymous


Under supervision, individuals are often given objectives to follow - terms of their supervision or rules set for them governing their lives outside of prison - that do not violate a law in Minnesota. These terms might include things like curfews or constraints on travel. If someone breaks those rules, the system calls this “Technical Violations.”   

When a judge revokes someone’s probation and sends them back to prison for a technical violation, it can undo months or even years of progress.


Consider these real-world examples of the system failing people making real progress:


  • The Overridden Expert: In a real-life experience, one gentleman suffered a setback where his addiction, environment, and lack of support led to a relapse. However, he had the full support of his probation officer to enter an inpatient treatment program. Despite the probation officer and mental health expert, the judge rejected the path toward treatment and sent him back to prison instead. (State of Minnesota, Respondent, v. Joseph Robert Udstuen)


  • Judging a person’s character: As in State of Minnesota v. Joseph Robert Udstuen, the judge and his probation officer previously deemed him not a threat to the community, and that remaining in the community would be the best environment for him. The technical violation resulted in a decision against everyone else involved and sent him to prison for the remainder of his sentence. This subjective decision-making could be seen as violating the spirit of the law and failing to understand the individual's and the community's true needs. In almost all cases, these individuals are considered “not a threat to public safety”; under this classification, the best course should rarely, if ever, be to send them to prison.


Prison Warehousing vs. Community Success


"Those who have short incarceration use up resources otherwise needed for those who have a significant amount of time remaining in their sentence."— Anonymous


Since COVID-19, many rehabilitative programs inside Minnesota Correctional Facilities have closed permanently and services are severely limited. When individuals with technical violations are forced back into the system, they crowd the prison. They take up physical bed space, tie up phone lines, and overwhelm mental health staff. Because these individuals are often fast-tracked for treatment, they push long-term inmates further down the waiting list. In addition, many short-term inmates are just briefly warehoused and do not get any treatment at all. And this is not a small number: In 2025, MNJRC found that 48% of all people released from prison had served less than one year. 


The correctional system costs Minnesota taxpayers $1.24 billion biannually. Of that, $30 million is budgeted for mental health. An additional $15 million is spent on drug and alcohol treatment. Approximately 90% of the population in prison has a drug or alcohol addiction and is required to attend treatment. While in prison, only 25% can fulfill that requirement. The remaining individuals fulfill that requirement once released.

(All figures came from mn.gov)


The Bottom Line


This creates a major contradiction in Austin Factor #3: “someone would benefit more from being incarcerated than from a clear path in the community”. The community is where true rehabilitation happens. In the community, individuals have access to better facilities, family networks, and real-world stability. Sending someone back to prison for a technical violation must be treated as an absolute last resort. Keeping people in their communities—where they can access mental health care and maintain their livelihoods—is, and always will be, the best path forward.



Andrew Fair is a student worker with TREC and the REBUILD Initiative, as well as the Sunshine Lady Foundation. While pursuing his graduate degree in Advocacy and Political Leadership at Metro State University, Andrew centers his work on restorative justice and community healing. He is dedicated to supporting justice-impacted individuals, empowering incarcerated fathers, and strengthening family bonds to drive meaningful prison reform and community growth.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page